City's math, reading programs are failing our children
May 11, 2011 | 5978 views | 1 1 comments | 49 49 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Dear Editor

As a parent of a 2nd grader student in District 25, I have observed some disturbing trends over the last several years in schools citywide and in the school my daughter goes to. Our wonderful, veteran teachers are being forced out into early retirement by abusive administrators. These teachers were such an asset to our schools. With their educational expertise and experience, they were often the teachers you turned to for educational advice.

Many of our schools are now filled with inept and inexperienced principals, many from the Leadership Academy, and novice teachers who are not lasting more than a few years. The turnover rate for principals and teacher is alarming and detrimental to our schools.

In addition, there is the widespread use of a balanced literacy reading and writing curriculum also known as Teachers College and a fuzzy math program known as Everyday Mathematics. At best, the programs are lacking in many ways and need to be supplemented with other programs because of their deficiencies My daughter spends the majority of her day working with a partner, reading on her own or sitting in the meeting area just listening to her teacher.

Little, if any, contest is taught.

Hallway bulletin boards are loaded with “Published Works” which contain misspellings, incorrect grammar and incorrect punctuation. Phonics and grammar instruction is frowned upon and teachers are even punished by these new principals.

It doesn't get any better in the upper grades and I've learned that proponents of balanced literacy believe that focusing on these things stifles creativity. But how can you be a successful writer when you haven't mastered the basic writing skills? Math experts from all over the country have analyzed the Everyday Mathematics program and have stated that the program is so lacking, it should NEVER be used in elementary schools because it does not prepare students for higher math.

But administrators are prepared to tell parents that it's a “spiraling” program and if your child doesn't master a skill the first time, they will master it next time. And if your child has any difficulty, they can just reach for a calculator. Math professors argue that these are poor methods of teaching basic math skills and leaves kids behind.

After some careful research, it became clear to me that the DOE made the wrong move with these programs. Why did the DOE implement unproven, not research-based, highly controversial programs when there were so many wonderful research-based programs already in place?

Parents should speak with the principals and demand they remove these terrible programs from their child's school. Many principals know the harm of these programs but keep them because it's cost-effective to do so. Some parents in the district have been successful in having these two programs removed from their schools. It's time they are removed from all schools.


James Chin

College Point
Comments-icon Post a Comment
May 12, 2011
Totally agree, they are awful programs. Children are going to middle school and high school totally unprepared for advanced math or english. I am sure in a few years someone at the DOE will realize the balanced literacy and spiraling math do not work and they will change it. It will be too late for many children. The DOE needs to fix this sooner rather than later.